Dissertation Defense, Swedish style
After 3 years with no one graduating, last Friday was the first of 3 consecutive Friday dissertation defenses at the department. Like my arrival, the defenses were originally scheduled for January then delayed due to Omicron so they could be held in person. The process of defending a dissertation varies remarkably across countries, at least based on my personal experiences in the US, the Netherlands, and the UK where I've seen 3 very different models. Sweden is now a 4th model. At Pitt, the committee consists of 3 departmental faculty and at least one outside member (often a faculty from another department at Pitt). The candidate sends us a draft document at least two weeks in advance. The student gives a public one hour presentation followed by an open question session, then there is a private QA with the committee. After that the committee decides if the student passes, and usually the student is asked to make some writing and sometimes even new research ...